.
Wer die Jugend hat, hat die Zukunft.
— Karl Liebknecht
.
In a civilization that’s grown old, ours is a culture that prizes youth. No longer as presage to a radiant future, but part of a permanent present. Philosophy paints its gray on gray onto the pages of Teen Vogue, the Arab Spring followed by an Islamist Winter. From Young Thug to la jeune-fille — to the familiar refrain of “I like their early stuff better” — all beauty is fleeting, as the proverb goes. A season or so later, it loses its luster. Efforts at reinvention or renovation more often than not end up a laughing stock. Worse yet: ignored. Modernity thrives off the ephemeral, Baudelaire noticed long ago, to the point that an entire style took youth as its theme. “Jugendstil is a declaration of permanent puberty,” observed Adorno, “a utopia that barters off its own unrealizability… Hatred of the new originates in a concealed tenet of bourgeois ontology: that the transient should be transient, that death should have the last word.”
Raoul Peck’s film Der junge Karl Marx premiered last month in Berlin. It’s his second major release already this year, the first being I am Not Your Negro, a documentary based on the life of the African-American writer James Baldwin. Though it was nominated for an academy award, the Haitian filmmaker’s effort ultimately lost out to the five-part ESPN epic OJ Simpson: Made in America. Most of the Marx biopic was shot in Belgium back in 2015. While I’m always wary of silver screen portrayals of great historical figures, I personally can’t wait to see it. As a way of celebrating its debut, then, I’m posting several major articles and essays on the theme of the “young” Marx. Usually, the younger Marx is contrasted with or counterposed to the older Marx, although the dates assigned to each phase is a matter of some controversy among scholars. If you don’t believe me, just glance at the following pieces to get a sense of the wide range of opinions:
- Erich Fromm, “The Continuity in Marx’s Thought” (1961)
- Gajo Petrović, “The ‘Young’ and the ‘Old’ Marx” (1964)
- Louis Althusser, “On The Young Marx” (1960) and “The Evolution of the ‘Young’ Marx” (1974)
- Iring Fetscher, “The Young and the Old Marx” (1970)
- István Mészáros, “The Controversy about Marx” (1970)
- Paul Mattick, “Review of Marx Before Marxism” (1971)
- Lucio Colletti, Introduction to The Early Writings of Karl Marx (1973)
- Michel Henry, “The Humanism of the Young Marx” (1976)