.
Haitian revolutionary leader and statesman Toussaint Louverture was born 274 years ago today. You can read a number of books, essays, and articles by clicking on the links below.
- CLR James, The Black Jacobins: Toussaint L’Ouverture and the Haitian Revolution (1938)
- CLR James, Lectures on The Black Jacobins (1974)
- Laurent Dubois, Avengers of the New World: The Story of the Haitian Revolution (2004)
- Jeremy D. Popkin, Facing Racial Revolution: Eyewitness Accounts of the Haitian Insurrection (2008)
- Susan Buck-Morss, Hegel, Haiti, and Universal History (2009)
- Jeremy D. Popkin, A Concise History of the Haitian Revolution (2011)
Foremost among these, of course, is CLR James’ classic The Black Jacobins: Toussaint Louverture and the Haitian Revolution (1938). Against the naïve imperative that says “we must not censor works hailed by the subaltern as masterful pieces of our history, but instead celebrate them if the subaltern says we should” — which almost reads like a reductio ad absurdum of standpoint epistemology — we ought rather to uphold those works which pass critical and scholarly muster. James’ book, though not written by an academic, stands up brilliantly to this test.
Some of the others are also worth checking out. In particular, Susan Buck-Morss’ influential study of Hegel, Haiti, and Universal History (2009), which caused something of a stir when the first half was published as an essay back in 2001. “Decolonial dialectician” George Ciccariello-Maher criticized her for focusing too much on Toussaint, at the expense of his compatriot Jean-Jacques Dessalines. Nevertheless, out of these two, I greatly prefer Toussaint.
James repeatedly compared Toussaint to Robespierre, and in this analogy Dessalines could only be compared to Napoleon. After selling Toussaint out to Leclerc, and disposing of rivals such as Charles and Sanité Bélair, Dessalines crowned himself emperor and ruled with an iron fist over the ex-colonial island. Marx, as we know, had little patience for would-be New World Napoleons like Simon Bolivar, so it’s not hard to imagine what he would have thought of Dessalines.
But even beyond these monographs and histories, Toussaint’s life has inspired works by great literary figures as well. To honor and commemorate his birthday, then, I’m also including a poem dedicated to Toussaint by the poet William Wordsworth and a short story by the novelist Ralph Ellison. Enjoy!
To Toussaint L’Ouverture
William Wordsworth
The Morning Post
February 4, 1802
.
.
Toussaint, the most unhappy man of men!
…Whether the whistling Rustic tend his plough
Within thy hearing, or thy head be now
…Pillowed in some deep dungeon’s earless den; —
O miserable Chieftain! where and when
…Wilt thou find patience? Yet die not; do thou
Wear rather in thy bonds a cheerful brow:
…Though fallen thyself, never to rise again,
Live, and take comfort. Thou hast left behind
…Powers that will work for thee; air, earth, and skies;
There’s not a breathing of the common wind
…That will forget thee; thou hast great allies;
Thy friends are exultations, agonies,
…And love, and man’s unconquerable mind.
Mister Toussan
Ralph Ellison
New Masses
Nov. 4, 1941
.
.
Once upon a time
The goose drink wine
Monkey chew tobacco
And he spit white lime— Rhyme used as a prologue
to Negro slave stories
“I hope they all gits rotten and the worms git in ’em,” the first boy said. “I hopes a big wind storm comes and blows down all the trees,” said the second boy.
……“Me too,” the first boy said. “And when ole Rogan comes out to see what happened I hope a tree falls on his head and kills him.”
……“Now jus look a-yonder at them birds,” the second boy said. “They eating all they want and when we asked him to let us git some off the ground he had to come calling us little nigguhs and chasing us home!”
……“Doggonit,” said the second boy. “I hope them birds got poison in they feet!”
……The two small boys, Riley and Buster, sat on the floor of the porch, their bare feet resting upon the cool earth as they stared past the line on the paving where the sun consumed the shade, to a yard directly across the street. The grass in the yard was very green, and a house stood against it, neat and white in the morning sun. A double row of trees stood alongside the house, heavy with cherries that showed deep red against the dark green of the leaves and dull dark brown of the branches. The two boys were watching an old man who rocked himself in a chair as he stared back at them across the street.
……“Just look at him,” said Buster. “Ole Rogan’s so scared we gonna git some a his ole cherries he ain’t even got sense enough to go in outa the sun!”
……“Well, them birds is gitting their’n,” said Riley.
……“They mockingbirds.”
……“I don’t care what kinda birds they is, they sho in them trees.”
……“Yeah, ole Rogan don’t see them. Man, I tell you white folks ain’t got no sense.”
……They were silent now, watching the darting flight of the birds into the trees. Behind them they could hear the clatter of a sewing machine: Riley’s mother was sewing for the white folks. It was quiet, and as the woman worked, her voice rose above the whirring machine in song.
……“Your mama sho can sing, man,” said Buster.
……“She sings in the choir,” said Riley, “and she sings all the leads in church.”
……“Shucks, I know it,” said Buster. “You tryin’ to brag?”
……As they listened they heard the voice rise clear and liquid to float upon the morning air:
I got wings, you got wings,
All God’s chillun got a wings
When I git to heaven gonna put on my wings
Gonna shout all ovah God’s heab’n.
Heab’n, heab’n
Everbody talkin’ ’bout heab’n ain’t going there
Heab’n, heab’n, Ah’m gonna fly all ovah God’s heab’n…
She sang as though the words possessed a deep and throbbing meaning for her, and the boys stared blankly at the earth, feeling the somber, mysterious calm of church. The street was quiet, and even old Rogan had stopped rocking to listen. Finally the voice trailed off to a hum and became lost in the clatter of the busy machine.
……“Wish I could sing like that,” said Buster.
……Riley was silent, looking down to the end of the porch where the sun had eaten a bright square into the shade, fixing a flitting butterfly in its brilliance.
……“What would you do if you had wings?” he said.
……“Shucks, I’d outfly an eagle. I wouldn’t stop flying till I was a million, billion, trillion, zillion miles away from this ole town.”
……“Where’d you go, man?”
……“Up north, maybe to Chicago.”
……“Man, if I had wings I wouldn’t never settle down.”
……“Me neither. Hecks, with wings you could go anywhere, even up to the sun if it wasn’t too hot…”
……“…I’d go to New York…”
……“Even around the stars…”
……“Or Dee-troit, Michigan…”
……“Hell, you could git some cheese off the moon and some milk from the Milky Way…”
……“Or anywhere else colored is free…”
……“I bet I’d loop-the-loop…”
……“And parachute…”
……“I’d land in Africa and git me some diamonds…”
……“Yeah, and them cannibals would eat the hell outa you, too,” said Riley.
……“The heck they would, not as fast as I’d fly away…”
……“Man, they’d catch you and stick some them long spears in your behin’!” said Riley.
……Buster laughed as Riley shook his head gravely: “Boy, you’d look like a black pincushion when they got through with you,” said Riley.
……“Shucks, man, they couldn’t catch me, them suckers is too lazy. The geography book says they ’bout the most lazy folks in the whole world,” said Buster with disgust, “just black and lazy!”
……“Aw naw, they ain’t neither,” exploded Riley.
……“They is too! The geography book says they is!”
……“Well, my old man says they ain’t!”
……“How come they ain’t then?”
……“…’Cause my old man says that over there they got kings and diamonds and gold and ivory, and if they got all them things, all of ’em caint be lazy,” said Riley.
……“Ain’t many colored folks over here got them things.”
……“Sho ain’t, man. The white folks won’t let ’em,” said Buster.
……It was good to think that all the Africans were not lazy. He tried to remember all he had heard of Africa as he watched a purple pigeon sail down into the street and scratch where a horse had passed. Then, as he remembered a story his teacher had told him, he saw a car rolling swiftly up the street and the pigeon stretching its wings and lifting easily into the air, skimming the top of the car in its slow, rocking flight. He watched it rise and disappear where the taut telephone wires cut the sky above the curb. Buster felt good. Riley scratched his initials in the soft earth with his big toe.
……“Riley, you know all them Africa guys ain’t really that lazy,” he said.
……“I know they ain’t,” said Riley. “I just tole you so.”
……“Yeah, but my teacher tole me, too. She tole us ’bout one of the African guys named Toussan what she said whipped Napoleon!”
……Riley stopped scratching in the earth and looked up, his eye rolling in disgust:
……“Now how come you have to start lying?”
……“Thass what she said.”
……“Boy, you oughta quit telling them things.”
……“I hope God may kill me.”
……“She said he was a African?”
……“Cross my heart, man…”
……“Really?”
……“Really, man. She said he come from a place named Hayti.”
……Riley looked hard at Buster and, seeing the seriousness of the face, felt the excitement of a story rise up within him.
……“Buster, I’ll bet a fat man you lyin’. What’d that teacher say?”
……“Really, man, she said that Toussan and his men got up on one of them African mountains and shot down them peckerwood soldiers fass as they’d try to come up…”
……“Why good-God-a-mighty!” yelled Riley.
……“Oh boy, they shot ’em down!” chanted Buster.
……“Tell me about it, man!”
……“And they throwed ’em off the mountain…”
……“…Goool-leee!…”
……“…And Toussan drove ’em cross the sand…”
……“…Yeah! And what was they wearing, Buster?…”
……“Man, they had on red uniforms and blue hats all trimmed with gold and they had some swords all shining, what they called sweet blades of Damascus…”
……“Sweet blades of Damascus!…”
……“…They really had ’em,” chanted Buster.
……“And what kinda guns?”
……“Big, black cannon!”
……“And where did ole what you call ’im run them guys?…”
……“His name was Toussan.”
……“Toozan! Just like Tarzan…”
……“Not Taar-zan, dummy, Toou-zan!”
……“Toussan! And where’d ole Toussan run ’em?”
……“Down to the water, man…”
……“…To the river water…”
……“…Where some great big ole boats was waiting for ’em…”
……“…Go on, Buster!”
……“An’ Toussan shot into them boats…”
……“…He shot into ’em…”
……“…shot into them boats…”
……“Jesus!…”
……“…with his great big cannons…”
……“…Yeah!…”
……“…made a-brass…”
……“…Brass…”
……“…an’ his big black cannonballs started killin’ them peckerwoods…”
……“…Lawd, Lawd…”
……“…Boy, till them peckerwoods hollowed, Please, Please, Mister Toussan, we’ll be good!”
……“An’ what’d Toussan tell ’em, Buster?”
……“Boy, he said in his deep voice, I oughta drown all a you bastards.”
……“An’ what’d the peckerwoods say?”
……“They said, Please, Please, Please, Mister Toussan…”
……“…We’ll be good,” broke in Riley.
……“Thass right, man,” said Buster excitedly. He clapped his hands and kicked his heels against the earth, his black face glowing in a burst of rhythmic joy.
……“Boy!”
……“And what’d ole Toussan say then?”
……“He said in his big deep voice: You all peckerwoods better be good, ’cause this is sweet Papa Toussan talking and my nigguhs is crazy ’bout white meat!”
……“Ho, ho, ho!” Riley bent double with laughter. The rhythm still throbbed within him and he wanted the story to go on and on…
……“Buster, you know didn’t no teacher tell you that lie,” he said.
……“Yes, she did, man.”
……“She said there was really a guy like that what called hisself Sweet Papa Toussan?”
……Riley’s voice was unbelieving, and there was a wistful expression in his eyes that Buster could not understand. Finally, he dropped his head and grinned.
……“Well,” he said, “I bet thass what ole Toussan said. You know how grown folks is, they caint tell a story right ’cepting real old folks like Granma.”
……“They sho caint,” said Riley. “They don’t know how to put the right stuff to it.”
……Riley stood, his legs spread wide, and stuck his thumbs in the top of his trousers, swaggering sinisterly.
……“Come on, watch me do it now, Buster. Now I bet ole Toussan looked down at them white folks standing just about like this and said in a soft easy voice: Ain’t I done begged you white folks to quit messin’ with me?…”
……“Thass right, quit messing with ’im,” chanted Buster.
……“But naw, you all had to come on anyway…”
……“…Just ’cause they was black…”
……“Thass right,” said Riley. “Then ole Toussan felt so damn bad and mad the tears came a-trickling down…”
……“…He was really mad.”
……“And then, man, he said in his big, bad voice: Goddamn you white folks, how come you all caint let us colored alone?”
……“…An’ he was crying…”
……“…An’ Toussan tole them peckerwoods: I been beggin’ you all to quit bothering us…”
……“…Beggin’ on his bended knees! …”
……“Then, man, Toussan got real mad and snatched off his hat and started stompin’ up and down on it and the tears was tricklin’ down and he said: You all come tellin’ me about Napoleon…”
……“They was tryin’ to scare ’im, man…”
……“Said: I don’t give a damn about Napoleon…”
……“…Wasn’t studyin’ ’bout him…”
……“…Toussan said: Napoleon ain’t nothing but a man! Then Toussan pulled back his shining sword like this, and twirled it at them peckerwoods’ throats so hard it z-z-z-zinged in the air!”
……“Now keep on, finish it, man,” said Buster. “What’d Toussan do then?”
……“Then you know what he did, he said: I oughta beat the hell outa you peckerwoods!”
……“Thass right, and he did it too,” said Buster.
……He jumped to his feet and fenced violently with five desperate imaginary soldiers, running each through with his imaginary sword. Buster watched him from the porch, grinning.
……“Toussan musta scared them white folks almost to death!”
……“Yeah, thass ’bout the way it was,” said Buster. The rhythm was dying now and he sat back upon the porch, breathing tiredly.
……“It sho is a good story,” said Riley.
……“Hecks, man, all the stories my teacher tells us is good. She’s a good ole teacher — but you know one thing?”
……“Naw, what?”
……“Ain’t none of them stories in the books. Wonder why?”
……“Hell, you know why. Ole Toussan was too hard on them white folks, thass why.”
……“Oh, he was a hard man!”
……“He was mean…”
……“But a good mean!”
……“Toussan was clean…”
……“… He was a good, clean mean,” said Riley.
……“Aw, man, he was sooo-preme,” said Buster.
……“Riiiley!!”
……The boys stopped short in their word play, their mouths wide.
……“Riley, I say!” It was Riley’s mother’s voice.
……“Ma’m?”
……“She musta heard us cussin’,” whispered Buster.
……“Shut up, man… What you want, Ma?”
……“I says I want you all to go round the backyard and play. You keeping up too much fuss out there. White folks says we tear up a neighborhood when we move in it and you all out there jus provin’ them out true. Now git on round in the back.”
……“Aw, Ma, we was jus playing, Ma…”
……“Boy, I said for you all to go on.”
……“But, Ma…”
……“You hear me, boy!”
……“Yessum, we going,” said Riley. “Come on, Buster.”
……Buster followed slowly behind, feeling the dew upon his feet as he walked up on the shaded grass.
……“What else did he do, man?” Buster said.—
……“Huh? Rogan?”
……“Hecks, naw! I’m talkin’ ’bout Toussan.”
……“Doggone if I know, man — but I’m gonna ask that teacher.”
……“He was a fightin’ son-of-a-gun, wasn’t he, man?”
……“He didn’t stand for no foolishness,” said Riley reservedly.
……He thought of other things now, and as he moved along, he slid his feet easily over the short-cut grass, dancing as he chanted:
Iron is iron,
And tin is tin,
And that’s the way
The story…
“Aw come on, man,” interrupted Buster. “Let’s go play in the alley…”
……And that’s the way…
……“Maybe we can slip around and get some cherries,” Buster went on.
……… the story ends, chanted Riley
Thanks, this is a good little collection of texts. If you can find a pdf, it might be good to include CLR James’ play about ‘Toussaint Louverture: The Story of the Only Successful Slave Revolt in History’.
Ross “No guys, I’m totally not a racist” Wolfe, ladies and gentlemen!
Didn’t I tell you to go outside and stop writing? The sun isn’t so bad, you know, and you may encounter new experiences and perspectives that you’ve lacked because you were too busy doing whatever you want to call this self-indulgent internet and academic tripe.
It certainly isn’t Marxist or Communist, it likely meets today’s popular definition of “left” in the United States. I cannot picture what the permanent revolution you imagine yourself to be part of looks like, but it probably involves plenty of apologia for empire. Well not probably, it does.
Good luck! Wear sunscreen!
Failing to find activities to do outside and to ward off boredom, maybe you could find a shovel, lift it, dig a hole, then fill it back up, and then imagine what those of us who actually perform labor using our bodies for a living might go through.
I think this is called empathy but I am just a stupid moron who didn’t complete college and is incapable of understanding things nearly as well as you do, so just imagine what sort of Mr. Big Dick you’d be if you could conceivably do more than just write your very important and fancy academic words for an even more niche audience than Red Kahina.
Love,
A trade unionist
I’m not sure what you’re getting at. You’ll find plenty of stuff about the Haitian Revolution on this blog going back over the years, so this is not just something I’ve recently become interested in.
What do you mean by “empire”? Have Marxists really fallen so far that they now use this stupid Hardt/Negri idiom?
What am I getting at? I didn’t think I was being obtuse. Surely someone as brilliant as yourself can figure it out. I eagerly await your contribution to, well, anything at this point, Ross.
(DON’T CALL ME SHIRLEY)